And so the Report Card series comes to a close. Amazing that up till today guys were getting signed. In this case Felipe Lopez with the Cards. Anyways, Spring Training is well underway, so enjoy!
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS
Major Signings: Matt Holliday, Felipe Lopez, Brad Penny, Rich Hill
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Mark DeRosa, Troy Glaus, Rick Ankiel, Joel Piniero, Todd Wellemeyer
Report: While the Cards shed some players this offseason their aquististions were well spent. Matt Holliday was their giant purchase, but after seeing what he did behind Albert Pujols he was a must have. Assuming they extend Pujols, this will be among the best 3-4's in baseball. Brad Penny was the only major addition to the rotation, although Rich Hill will get a chance to compete for the fifth spot. Can Penny continue what he started in San Francisco late last year? If so, their top four are fairly decent. And bringing back Felipe Lopez is a fantastic late signing.
Overall: Overall, pretty good.
Grade: B+
CHICAGO CUBS
Major Signings: Marlon Byrd, Xavier Nady, Kevin Millar, Chad Tracy, John Grabow
Major Trade Acquisitions: Carlos Silva
Major Losses: Milton Bradley, Aaron Heilman, Rich Harden, Kevin Gregg, Reed Johnson, Neal Cotts
Report: Their biggest move was getting rid of headache Milton Bradley, of course they got Carlos Silva for him, but if he makes a "comeback" he could be a run of the mill 5th starter. Marlon Byrd and Xavier Nady are the outfield replacements. Byrd could surpass Bradley's output with another decent season. Those are all OK moves, but the small signing of John Grabow to a big contract was quite silly.
Overall: OK at best. I think their outfield is stronger than it was last year, but otherwise that's about it. Replacing Rich Harden with Carlos Silva is not good.
Grade: C
MILWAUKEE BREWERS
Major Signings: Randy Wolf, Doug Davis, LaTroy Hawkins, Scott Schoeneweis, Jim Edmonds, Kameron Loe, Claudio Vargas, Gregg Zaun
Major Trade Acquisitions: Carlos Gomez
Major Losses: J.J Hardy, Mike Rivera, Seth McClung, Jason Kendall, Frank Catalanotto
Report: The Brew Crew were pretty crafty this offseason. They strengthened both their rotation and bullpen with the big catch being Randy Wolf. Did they overpay for him? Possibly, but I like his chances for a repeat performance from last year, and Doug Davis provides another solid, if unexciting, starter. They also traded away J.J. Hardy for the speedy Carlos Gomez. Can the youngster realize his potential? If so, this was a fantastic deal.
Overall: Others might not, but I liked Milwaukee's offseason. They had needs and filled them to their means.
Grade: B+
CINCINNATI REDS
Major Signings: Aroldis Chapman, Orlando Cabrera, Jonny Gomes, Kip Wells, Laynce Nix
Major Trade Acquisitions: Aaron Miles
Major Losses: Wily Taveras
Report: They spent their cash on Cuban defect Aroldis Chapman. Oh, and Orlando Cabrera who is declining, but has a ton of postseason experience. Not that this team will benefit from that.
Overall: Meh, the Chapman signing was a lot of risk.
Grade: C
HOUSTON ASTROS
Major Signings: Brandon Lyon, Pedro Feliz, Brett Myers
Major Trade Acquisitions: Matt Lindstrom
Major Losses: Jose Valverde, Miguel Tejada, LaTroy Hawkins
Report: Jose Valverde and LaTroy Hawkins gone, Brandon Lyon and Matt Lindstrom in. The latter replacement made for a good trade, but Brandon Lyon was grossly overpaid. Disgustingly even. The two will be battling for the closer's job, but with the money Lyon is getting (3 years for 15 mil) you have to assume he's the odds on favorite. Either way, it's going to get scary down in Texas. Pedro Feliz replaces Miguel Tejada, mostly with his glove, and Brett Myers looks to return to form on his new team.
Overall: I dunno, these signings have all kinds of red flags. Just on the Lyon signing alone you have to give it a bad grade.
Grade: D
PITTSBURGH PIRATES
Major Signings: Octavio Dotel, Ryan Church, Brendan Donnelly
Major Trade Acquisitions: Akinori Iwamura
Major Losses: Matt Capps
Report: So, I somehow deleted this Pirates entry twice, which is always good to make me nuts. Of course, it's the last entry! Why are there so many teams in the NL Central?! That makes me crazy as well. Can't we realign so that Houston goes to the NL West and one of those teams goes to the AL West? This isn't rocket science!
Overall: Dotel is better than Capps, Aki is equal to Freddie Sanchez. That's a wrap.
Grade: B-
Saturday, February 27, 2010
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
HOT STOVE REPORT CARD: NL WEST
The finish line lies ahead with only two divisions left. First up the NL West where the Dodgers will have even a harder time this year with some improvements around the divisions, and a lack of improvement for themselves.
LOS ANGELES DODGERS
Major Signings: Jamey Carroll, Vincente Padilla, Luis Ayala, Ronnie Belliard, Russ Ortiz, Nick Green, Doug Mientkiewicz, Brad Ausmus, Jeff Weaver, Brian Giles, Alfredo Amezaga
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Randy Wolf, Jim Thome, Orlando Hudson, Jon Garland, Juan Pierre
Report: Besides resigning most of their supporting crew and adding to that, this team did nothing. They lost a major rotation piece in Randy Wolf, and didn't even bring back Jon Garland. An ugly off-field divorce of the owners has caused all of this, and that's just a shame. The best thing they did was lock up some of their key young players.
Overall: Locking up your youngsters is definitely a good thing, as at least it guarantees a core, but they seriously needed another pitcher and didn't get that. They will feel that for sure.
Grade: D
COLORADO ROCKIES
Major Signings: Miguel Olivo, Jason Giambi, Melvin Mora, Tim Redding, Jimmy Gobble, Paul LoDuca, Jay Payton, Justin Spier
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Matt Murton, Josh Fogg, Jose Contreras, Yorvit Torrealba, Jason Marquis
Report: This is a team that really didn't need much, and so they really didn't do much besides adding a bit of depth. Most notably, they brought in Melvin Mora as infield insurance policy, they replaced Yorvit Torrealba with Miguel Olivo, and brought back clubhouse captain Jason Giambi.
Overall: Not much to say here as a solid team didn't do anything crazy, and that's just fine.
Grade: B
SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS
Major Signings: Mark DeRosa, Aubrey Huff, Juan Uribe, Bengie Molina, Todd Wellemeyer, Guillermo Mota,
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Ryan Garko, Randy Johnson, Brad Penny, Randy Winn
Report: While the Giants needed some real power, they instead brought in some possible power in Mark DeRosa and Aubrey Huff, the latter coming off a terrible season. For what it's worth, they did try to sign Adam LaRoche for two years only to be shockingly shunned. However, the two signings could help them and they did resign two factors from last year: Bengie Molina and Juan Uribe. Is this enough? We'll see.
Overall: A meh off-season. After missing out on LaRoche I probably would've went for Russell Branyon instead of Huff, but that's just me. Johnny Damon would've been better than DeRosa as well.
Grade: C
SAN DIEGO PADRES
Major Signings: Jon Garland, Jerry Hairston Jr., Yorvit Torrealba, Matt Stairs
Major Trade Acquisitions: Scott Hairston
Major Losses: Kevin Kouzmanoff, Brian Giles, Henry Blanco
Report: Under new GM Jed Hoyer, the Padres quietly made some alright moves. They traded away Kevin Kouzmanoff to bring back Scott Hairston and a good prospect, they signed a much needed veteran pitcher in Jon Garland, brought in Torrealba to platoon with Nick Hundley, and added Matt Stairs and Jerry Hairston Jr. to their bench. Not blow you out of the water moves, but solid, little ones that'll help this team be better this year.
Overall: What I just said.
Grade: B
ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS
Major Signings: Adam LaRoche, Kelly Johnson, Rodrigo Lopez, Bob Howry
Major Trade Acquisitions: Edwin Jackson, Ian Kennedy, Aaron Heilman
Major Losses: Max Scherzer, Eric Brynes, Daniel Schlereth, Doug Davis, Chad Tracy, Scott Schoenweiss
Report: The D'Backs were part of one of the biggest trades, no not the one that brought them Aaron Heilman, but the three team trade that kicked off the Winter Meetings in style. The one that sent Curtis Granderson to the Yankees, Austin Jackson, Max Scherzer, Daniel Schlereth, and Phil Coke to Detroit, and Edwin Jackson and Ian Kennedy to this team. Some say that the D'Backs got the short end of the stick, but they really traded a starter and a reliever for a more developed starter and another starter that could be good in this division, so that's not too bad. They also have a new right side of their infield in Adam LaRoche and Kelly Johnson, both former Braves. If Johnson can turn things around these will be good pick-ups for them.
Overall: They gave up some guys to some guys, they gave up on some other guys, they signed a couple of helpful players, not too shabby.
Grade: B-
LOS ANGELES DODGERS
Major Signings: Jamey Carroll, Vincente Padilla, Luis Ayala, Ronnie Belliard, Russ Ortiz, Nick Green, Doug Mientkiewicz, Brad Ausmus, Jeff Weaver, Brian Giles, Alfredo Amezaga
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Randy Wolf, Jim Thome, Orlando Hudson, Jon Garland, Juan Pierre
Report: Besides resigning most of their supporting crew and adding to that, this team did nothing. They lost a major rotation piece in Randy Wolf, and didn't even bring back Jon Garland. An ugly off-field divorce of the owners has caused all of this, and that's just a shame. The best thing they did was lock up some of their key young players.
Overall: Locking up your youngsters is definitely a good thing, as at least it guarantees a core, but they seriously needed another pitcher and didn't get that. They will feel that for sure.
Grade: D
COLORADO ROCKIES
Major Signings: Miguel Olivo, Jason Giambi, Melvin Mora, Tim Redding, Jimmy Gobble, Paul LoDuca, Jay Payton, Justin Spier
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Matt Murton, Josh Fogg, Jose Contreras, Yorvit Torrealba, Jason Marquis
Report: This is a team that really didn't need much, and so they really didn't do much besides adding a bit of depth. Most notably, they brought in Melvin Mora as infield insurance policy, they replaced Yorvit Torrealba with Miguel Olivo, and brought back clubhouse captain Jason Giambi.
Overall: Not much to say here as a solid team didn't do anything crazy, and that's just fine.
Grade: B
SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS
Major Signings: Mark DeRosa, Aubrey Huff, Juan Uribe, Bengie Molina, Todd Wellemeyer, Guillermo Mota,
Major Trade Acquisitions: none
Major Losses: Ryan Garko, Randy Johnson, Brad Penny, Randy Winn
Report: While the Giants needed some real power, they instead brought in some possible power in Mark DeRosa and Aubrey Huff, the latter coming off a terrible season. For what it's worth, they did try to sign Adam LaRoche for two years only to be shockingly shunned. However, the two signings could help them and they did resign two factors from last year: Bengie Molina and Juan Uribe. Is this enough? We'll see.
Overall: A meh off-season. After missing out on LaRoche I probably would've went for Russell Branyon instead of Huff, but that's just me. Johnny Damon would've been better than DeRosa as well.
Grade: C
SAN DIEGO PADRES
Major Signings: Jon Garland, Jerry Hairston Jr., Yorvit Torrealba, Matt Stairs
Major Trade Acquisitions: Scott Hairston
Major Losses: Kevin Kouzmanoff, Brian Giles, Henry Blanco
Report: Under new GM Jed Hoyer, the Padres quietly made some alright moves. They traded away Kevin Kouzmanoff to bring back Scott Hairston and a good prospect, they signed a much needed veteran pitcher in Jon Garland, brought in Torrealba to platoon with Nick Hundley, and added Matt Stairs and Jerry Hairston Jr. to their bench. Not blow you out of the water moves, but solid, little ones that'll help this team be better this year.
Overall: What I just said.
Grade: B
ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS
Major Signings: Adam LaRoche, Kelly Johnson, Rodrigo Lopez, Bob Howry
Major Trade Acquisitions: Edwin Jackson, Ian Kennedy, Aaron Heilman
Major Losses: Max Scherzer, Eric Brynes, Daniel Schlereth, Doug Davis, Chad Tracy, Scott Schoenweiss
Report: The D'Backs were part of one of the biggest trades, no not the one that brought them Aaron Heilman, but the three team trade that kicked off the Winter Meetings in style. The one that sent Curtis Granderson to the Yankees, Austin Jackson, Max Scherzer, Daniel Schlereth, and Phil Coke to Detroit, and Edwin Jackson and Ian Kennedy to this team. Some say that the D'Backs got the short end of the stick, but they really traded a starter and a reliever for a more developed starter and another starter that could be good in this division, so that's not too bad. They also have a new right side of their infield in Adam LaRoche and Kelly Johnson, both former Braves. If Johnson can turn things around these will be good pick-ups for them.
Overall: They gave up some guys to some guys, they gave up on some other guys, they signed a couple of helpful players, not too shabby.
Grade: B-
Sunday, February 21, 2010
HOT STOVE REPORT CARD: NL EAST
Part four in the Report Card series features the NL East, where the Phillies still rule with an iron fist.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES
Major Signings: Placido Polanco, Danys Baez, Ross Gload, Brian Schnieder, Jose Contreras
Major Trade Acquisitions: Roy Halladay
Major Losses: Cliff Lee, Pedro Feliz, Clay Condrey, pedro Martinez, Brett Myers, Scott Eyre, Eric Bruntlett, Matt Stairs, Chan Ho Park
Report: On the surface, it appears that the Phillies did really well for themselves. Coming off a second straight appearance in the World Series, there wasn't much to really do, but then they went and got Roy Halladay. A fanatastic move that unforunately gets kind of negated by the subsequent move of trading away Cliff Lee. This team was on the prescipice of having the best 1-2-3 in baseball, an almost a sure-fire third straight World Series appearance, and the clear favorite to win it all. GM Ruben Amaro apparently didn't want that, however. Since he knew he wouldn't resign Lee to the money he would garner, he opted to replenish a farm system that traded for both stud pitchers within 6 months. Not the worst idea, but none of the prospects in the Lee-to-the-Mariners trade were better than any they gave away, and again he let a sure thing go away. The thing about it is that they would've received 2 draft picks when Lee got signed next offseason anyway, so it didn't make much sense to trade him now. One extra prospect as compared to another Championship is absolutely nothing. Amaro was being too crafty for his own good. Moving on from there, they replaced Pedro Feliz with Placido Polanco in another move I don't like. Adrian Beltre and Chone Figgins were on the market, remember? Weird. Some interesting smaller moves could be good like bringing in Jose Contreras to pitch where ever they need him, and Ross Gload as a bench upgrade to Matt Stairs and Eric Bruntlett. Overall: Again, to me the Halladay/Lee trades are latteral moves, and the only thing that's a positive is that Doc is signed for the next three years. Oh, and duh, he's Doc freakin' Halladay. Otherwise it's been a mediorce offseason.
Grade: B+ *they also extended Joe Blanton, which changes my initial rating of a B to a B+. Thanks, Mike!
FLORIDA MARLINS
Major Signings: Mike MacDougal, Mike Lamb, Seth mcClung, Jose Veras, Derrick Turnbow,
Major Trade Acquisitions: Hunter Jones
Major Losses: Matt Lindstrom, Nick Johnson, Kiko Calero, Ross Gload, Brendan Donnelly, Jeremy Hermida
Report: Well, you really didn't expect the Marlins to do much, did you? They're cheap, and they're going to get by with their growing core of youngsters behind Hanley and Josh Johnson, and see where they go. Can't really fault them with the latter part of that.
Overall: When you know what you're getting into prior, you can't really call it bad, but you can't call it good either.
Grade: C
ATLANTA BRAVES
Major Signings: Billy Wagner, Takashi Saito, Troy Glaus, Eric Hinske
Major Trade Acquisitions: Melky Cabrera
Major Losses: Javier Vasquez, Boone Logan, Rafael Soriano, Mike Gonzalez, Kelly Johnson, Garret Anderson, Adam LaRoche
Report: The Braves made some cost-cutting moves this offseason, but maybe not the right ones. Trading Javier Vasquez coming off his best year was probably a mistake. They should've tried harder to get rid of Derek Lowe instead. Melky Cabrera was the only major league ready component of that trade, and he may finally get a full season to prove himself. In the NL, he may just do that, but will it be worth it for the Braves? We'll see. They also let their prime-time closing team of Rafael Soriano and Mike Gonzalez go to the AL East, and replaced them with the aging, but reliable, closing group of Billy Wagner and Takashi Saito. Was this a wise move? As far as experience, yes since these guys are proven commodities, but Wagner is still returning from major surgery, even though he looked good for the Red Sox down the stretch last year. They also signed Troy Glaus to play first base, a position he has some experience in, but not much. I thought Adam LaRoche should've been resigned here, but he didn't fit into the budget.
Overall: It's hard to say. They've added risk in Wagner, Saito, and Glaus, but when they are on they are very good players. Trading Vasquez, to me, was a mistake, though, and that drops them a bit.
Grade: B-
NEW YORK METS
Major Signings: Jason Bay, Rod Barajas, Mike Jacobs, Hisanori Takahashi, Frank Catalanotto, Shawn Riggins, Henry Blanco, Chris Coste, Fernando Tatis, Josh Fogg, R.A. Dickey, Kelvim Escobar, Ryota Igarashi, Alex Cora
Major Trade Acquisitions: Gary Matthews Jr.
Major Losses: J.J. Putz, Tim Redding, Jeremy Reed, Cory Sullivan, Brian Stokes
Report: Ah, the Mets, what can be said about New York's other team under their current management that hasn't already been said all over the place. They signed Jason Bay, a neccessary, good move, but look at the laundry list behind him. Instead of going out and signing someone of value they decided to put their strength in mediocre and under performing numbers. I mean, how many bad catchers do you need?! Rod Barajas will start, but it's anyone's guess who will back him up. They didn't address the need for a quality starter, so the number 5 starter will be a crap shoot. Carlos Beltran won't start the season because of knee surgery, which caused a mess with the team, so a combo of Angel Pagan and trade import Gary Matthews Jr. will do the honors. Needless to say, there are a bevy of question marks surrounding this team at a time where they could've used some stability,
Overall: They seemed to be in on everyone, and got virtually no one. Sure, Jason Bay gets them points, but the rest of their signings and non-signings coupled with various other issues that went on this offseason brings things down a couple of notches.
Grade: B-
WASHINGTON NATIONALS
Major Signings: Ivan Rodriguez, Jason Marquis, Chien-Ming Wang, Adam Kennedy, Matt Capps, Ron Villone, Willy Taveras, Miguel Batista, Chris Duncan, Eddie Guardado, Eric Bruntlett
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brian Bruney
Major Losses: Austin Kearns, Josh Bard
Report: I think the Nats did well for the Nats. This isn't a team that can easily lure free agents to them, but they did what thaey had to do. First, they remade their bullpen with Matt Capps taking over at closer, and Brian Bruney setting up; that's a hard throwing one-two. To their rotation they added Jason Marquis, a solid innings-eating guy, which is what they needed. He also provides some veteran presence to a young staff. Catching that young staff will now be Ivan Rodriguez, at least till Jesus Flores completely recovers from a torn labrum. That's good wisdom for Flores to absorb as well as the staff. Adam Kennedy, off a decent season with A's, takes over at second base as well, giving them another solid vet. Finally, they added a potential ace in Chien-Ming Wang, who will try to return to form later this spring. If he does, thats a huge boost to their staff.
Overall: Not bad, not bad at all. The Nats will improve this year for sure, and with some hot, young pitchers coming they'll improve even more!
Grade: B+
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES
Major Signings: Placido Polanco, Danys Baez, Ross Gload, Brian Schnieder, Jose Contreras
Major Trade Acquisitions: Roy Halladay
Major Losses: Cliff Lee, Pedro Feliz, Clay Condrey, pedro Martinez, Brett Myers, Scott Eyre, Eric Bruntlett, Matt Stairs, Chan Ho Park
Report: On the surface, it appears that the Phillies did really well for themselves. Coming off a second straight appearance in the World Series, there wasn't much to really do, but then they went and got Roy Halladay. A fanatastic move that unforunately gets kind of negated by the subsequent move of trading away Cliff Lee. This team was on the prescipice of having the best 1-2-3 in baseball, an almost a sure-fire third straight World Series appearance, and the clear favorite to win it all. GM Ruben Amaro apparently didn't want that, however. Since he knew he wouldn't resign Lee to the money he would garner, he opted to replenish a farm system that traded for both stud pitchers within 6 months. Not the worst idea, but none of the prospects in the Lee-to-the-Mariners trade were better than any they gave away, and again he let a sure thing go away. The thing about it is that they would've received 2 draft picks when Lee got signed next offseason anyway, so it didn't make much sense to trade him now. One extra prospect as compared to another Championship is absolutely nothing. Amaro was being too crafty for his own good. Moving on from there, they replaced Pedro Feliz with Placido Polanco in another move I don't like. Adrian Beltre and Chone Figgins were on the market, remember? Weird. Some interesting smaller moves could be good like bringing in Jose Contreras to pitch where ever they need him, and Ross Gload as a bench upgrade to Matt Stairs and Eric Bruntlett. Overall: Again, to me the Halladay/Lee trades are latteral moves, and the only thing that's a positive is that Doc is signed for the next three years. Oh, and duh, he's Doc freakin' Halladay. Otherwise it's been a mediorce offseason.
Grade: B+ *they also extended Joe Blanton, which changes my initial rating of a B to a B+. Thanks, Mike!
FLORIDA MARLINS
Major Signings: Mike MacDougal, Mike Lamb, Seth mcClung, Jose Veras, Derrick Turnbow,
Major Trade Acquisitions: Hunter Jones
Major Losses: Matt Lindstrom, Nick Johnson, Kiko Calero, Ross Gload, Brendan Donnelly, Jeremy Hermida
Report: Well, you really didn't expect the Marlins to do much, did you? They're cheap, and they're going to get by with their growing core of youngsters behind Hanley and Josh Johnson, and see where they go. Can't really fault them with the latter part of that.
Overall: When you know what you're getting into prior, you can't really call it bad, but you can't call it good either.
Grade: C
ATLANTA BRAVES
Major Signings: Billy Wagner, Takashi Saito, Troy Glaus, Eric Hinske
Major Trade Acquisitions: Melky Cabrera
Major Losses: Javier Vasquez, Boone Logan, Rafael Soriano, Mike Gonzalez, Kelly Johnson, Garret Anderson, Adam LaRoche
Report: The Braves made some cost-cutting moves this offseason, but maybe not the right ones. Trading Javier Vasquez coming off his best year was probably a mistake. They should've tried harder to get rid of Derek Lowe instead. Melky Cabrera was the only major league ready component of that trade, and he may finally get a full season to prove himself. In the NL, he may just do that, but will it be worth it for the Braves? We'll see. They also let their prime-time closing team of Rafael Soriano and Mike Gonzalez go to the AL East, and replaced them with the aging, but reliable, closing group of Billy Wagner and Takashi Saito. Was this a wise move? As far as experience, yes since these guys are proven commodities, but Wagner is still returning from major surgery, even though he looked good for the Red Sox down the stretch last year. They also signed Troy Glaus to play first base, a position he has some experience in, but not much. I thought Adam LaRoche should've been resigned here, but he didn't fit into the budget.
Overall: It's hard to say. They've added risk in Wagner, Saito, and Glaus, but when they are on they are very good players. Trading Vasquez, to me, was a mistake, though, and that drops them a bit.
Grade: B-
NEW YORK METS
Major Signings: Jason Bay, Rod Barajas, Mike Jacobs, Hisanori Takahashi, Frank Catalanotto, Shawn Riggins, Henry Blanco, Chris Coste, Fernando Tatis, Josh Fogg, R.A. Dickey, Kelvim Escobar, Ryota Igarashi, Alex Cora
Major Trade Acquisitions: Gary Matthews Jr.
Major Losses: J.J. Putz, Tim Redding, Jeremy Reed, Cory Sullivan, Brian Stokes
Report: Ah, the Mets, what can be said about New York's other team under their current management that hasn't already been said all over the place. They signed Jason Bay, a neccessary, good move, but look at the laundry list behind him. Instead of going out and signing someone of value they decided to put their strength in mediocre and under performing numbers. I mean, how many bad catchers do you need?! Rod Barajas will start, but it's anyone's guess who will back him up. They didn't address the need for a quality starter, so the number 5 starter will be a crap shoot. Carlos Beltran won't start the season because of knee surgery, which caused a mess with the team, so a combo of Angel Pagan and trade import Gary Matthews Jr. will do the honors. Needless to say, there are a bevy of question marks surrounding this team at a time where they could've used some stability,
Overall: They seemed to be in on everyone, and got virtually no one. Sure, Jason Bay gets them points, but the rest of their signings and non-signings coupled with various other issues that went on this offseason brings things down a couple of notches.
Grade: B-
WASHINGTON NATIONALS
Major Signings: Ivan Rodriguez, Jason Marquis, Chien-Ming Wang, Adam Kennedy, Matt Capps, Ron Villone, Willy Taveras, Miguel Batista, Chris Duncan, Eddie Guardado, Eric Bruntlett
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brian Bruney
Major Losses: Austin Kearns, Josh Bard
Report: I think the Nats did well for the Nats. This isn't a team that can easily lure free agents to them, but they did what thaey had to do. First, they remade their bullpen with Matt Capps taking over at closer, and Brian Bruney setting up; that's a hard throwing one-two. To their rotation they added Jason Marquis, a solid innings-eating guy, which is what they needed. He also provides some veteran presence to a young staff. Catching that young staff will now be Ivan Rodriguez, at least till Jesus Flores completely recovers from a torn labrum. That's good wisdom for Flores to absorb as well as the staff. Adam Kennedy, off a decent season with A's, takes over at second base as well, giving them another solid vet. Finally, they added a potential ace in Chien-Ming Wang, who will try to return to form later this spring. If he does, thats a huge boost to their staff.
Overall: Not bad, not bad at all. The Nats will improve this year for sure, and with some hot, young pitchers coming they'll improve even more!
Grade: B+
Thursday, February 18, 2010
HOT STOVE REPORT CARD: AL CENTRAL
*Updated 2/21/10 with Johnny Damon to the Tigers and Russell Branyon to the Indians.
Part three in the Report Card series features the AL Central, where the top three teams will still fight for the division, while the last two may switch places.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
MINNESOTA TWINS
Major Signings: Orlando Hudson, Jim Thome, Clay Condrey, Carl Pavano
Major Trade Acquisitions: J.J. Hardy
Major Losses: Orlando Cabrera, Carlos Gomez, Mike Redmond, Boof Bonser
Report: The always solid Twins made pretty good moves. They traded for J.J. Hardy and signed Orlando Hudson to create a more potent combo up the middle on offense and defense. Jim Thome gives them a strong bat off the bench that could DH regularly if they play Kubel and Cuddyer in the outfield corners and bench Delmon Young. They are also returning Carl Pavano who pitched well for them as he accepted arbitration from them.
Overall: They didn't lose much and gained more, so this team should be right back where they were at or close to the top of the division.
Grade: B+
DETROIT TIGERS
Major Signings: Jose Valverde, Adam Everett, Johnny Damon
Major Trade Acquisitions: Max Scherzer, Austin Jackson, Phil Coke, Daniel Schlereth
Major Losses: Curtis Granderson, Edwin Jackson, Placido Polanco, Fernando Rodney, Jarrod Washburn, Brandon Lyon, Marcus Thames, Aubrey Huff
Report: Some crazy moves for the Tigers this off-season, including a late signing of Johnny Damon! First off, though, they traded their stud center fielder Curtis Granderson and #2 starter Edwin Jackson in a mega three team deal with the Yankees and D'Backs. Not that their returns were bad, Max Scherzer has more upside than Edwin Jackson, Austin Jackson is like a younger Granderson without the power, and Schlereth and Coke will help their bullpen in front of new closer Jose Valverde. Grabbing Damon really helps their offense, although his power numbers will decrease in Commerica Park.
Overall: While many say they didn't like them giving up Granderson, I think AJAX is going make everyone shut up sooner than later. And they got younger in a few spots, saved a tad bit of money (even though they seem to be reinvesting it), got a more trustworthy closer, and added Damon. To me, that's pretty decent.
Grade: A-
CHICAGO WHITE SOX
Major Signings: Omar Vizquel, Andruw Jones, J.J. Putz, Freddie Garcia, Ramon Castro
Major Trade Acquisitions: Juan Pierre, Mark Teahen
Major Losses: Chris Getz, Josh Fields, Octavio Dotel, Scott Posednik,
Report: The South-Siders imported lots of spare parts that may or may not work out. Juan Pierre replaces Scott Posednik, and after Pierre's part-time showing last year, more of that could be beneficial to the Sox. Mark Teahen has a chance to prove himself at his best position (3rd), and Omar Vizquel was brought in to more than be his understudy. Andruw Jones will be a DH candidate unless Johnny Damon comes to camp. J.J. Putz will set-up for Bobby Jenks, and offer a bit of net should Jenks continue to regress.
Overall: No huge moves here, but complementary ones to go with the pieces that are there right now. Pierre and Teahen could really have the opportunity to make this team better. Is it a successful offseason? Quietly, I'd say yes, but again none of these moves bowl you over.
Grade: B-
CLEVELAND INDIANS
Major Signings: Mike Redmond, Mark Grudzielanek, Shelley Duncan, Austin Kearns, Russell Branyon
Major Trade Acquisitions: None
Major Losses: Kelly Shoppach, Jamey Carroll
Report: Hmm, well then there's the Indians, a team going severely backwards as they've shed most of their stars in the last couple of years, instead going with whatever good youth they have. Unfortunately, some of that youth is questionable, and they didn't do anything this off-season to help themselves. Heck Mike Redmond is the only guy listed as a major league signing, I put the other guys in because I felt bad! They brought back Russell Branyon to play first again, and Jake Westbrook is finally coming back to lead their staff, but this may be the year that KC overtakes them.
Overall: A bad offseason will lead to a bad season. Anything else will be a surprise.
Grade: D
KANSAS CITY ROYALS
Major Signings: Jason Kendall, Scott Posednik, Rick Ankiel, Brian Anderson
Major Trade Acquisitions: Chris Getz, Josh Fields
Major Losses: Mark Teahen, John Buck, Mike Jacobs, Miguel Olivo, Coco Crisp
Report: They've basically signed a whole new outfield, but they still have most of their old one! Huh?! I'm not a 100% sure I understand how GM Dayton Moore operates. Not that the signings are necessarily bad, but OK, they also traded Mark Teahen for Josh Fields and Chris Getz, which clogs up their infield as well. I guess Moore is just trying to give Trey Hillman as many options as possible, but more players (like Alex Gordon and Alberto Callapso) need to start establishing themselves on this team. And with all the catchers out there this year, including their own, they signed Jason Kendall...to two years!
Overall: The only thing I can say is that Moore was trying to improve their defense. In that way, good job, but I think these signings were unnecessary overkills.
Grade: C-
Part three in the Report Card series features the AL Central, where the top three teams will still fight for the division, while the last two may switch places.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
MINNESOTA TWINS
Major Signings: Orlando Hudson, Jim Thome, Clay Condrey, Carl Pavano
Major Trade Acquisitions: J.J. Hardy
Major Losses: Orlando Cabrera, Carlos Gomez, Mike Redmond, Boof Bonser
Report: The always solid Twins made pretty good moves. They traded for J.J. Hardy and signed Orlando Hudson to create a more potent combo up the middle on offense and defense. Jim Thome gives them a strong bat off the bench that could DH regularly if they play Kubel and Cuddyer in the outfield corners and bench Delmon Young. They are also returning Carl Pavano who pitched well for them as he accepted arbitration from them.
Overall: They didn't lose much and gained more, so this team should be right back where they were at or close to the top of the division.
Grade: B+
DETROIT TIGERS
Major Signings: Jose Valverde, Adam Everett, Johnny Damon
Major Trade Acquisitions: Max Scherzer, Austin Jackson, Phil Coke, Daniel Schlereth
Major Losses: Curtis Granderson, Edwin Jackson, Placido Polanco, Fernando Rodney, Jarrod Washburn, Brandon Lyon, Marcus Thames, Aubrey Huff
Report: Some crazy moves for the Tigers this off-season, including a late signing of Johnny Damon! First off, though, they traded their stud center fielder Curtis Granderson and #2 starter Edwin Jackson in a mega three team deal with the Yankees and D'Backs. Not that their returns were bad, Max Scherzer has more upside than Edwin Jackson, Austin Jackson is like a younger Granderson without the power, and Schlereth and Coke will help their bullpen in front of new closer Jose Valverde. Grabbing Damon really helps their offense, although his power numbers will decrease in Commerica Park.
Overall: While many say they didn't like them giving up Granderson, I think AJAX is going make everyone shut up sooner than later. And they got younger in a few spots, saved a tad bit of money (even though they seem to be reinvesting it), got a more trustworthy closer, and added Damon. To me, that's pretty decent.
Grade: A-
CHICAGO WHITE SOX
Major Signings: Omar Vizquel, Andruw Jones, J.J. Putz, Freddie Garcia, Ramon Castro
Major Trade Acquisitions: Juan Pierre, Mark Teahen
Major Losses: Chris Getz, Josh Fields, Octavio Dotel, Scott Posednik,
Report: The South-Siders imported lots of spare parts that may or may not work out. Juan Pierre replaces Scott Posednik, and after Pierre's part-time showing last year, more of that could be beneficial to the Sox. Mark Teahen has a chance to prove himself at his best position (3rd), and Omar Vizquel was brought in to more than be his understudy. Andruw Jones will be a DH candidate unless Johnny Damon comes to camp. J.J. Putz will set-up for Bobby Jenks, and offer a bit of net should Jenks continue to regress.
Overall: No huge moves here, but complementary ones to go with the pieces that are there right now. Pierre and Teahen could really have the opportunity to make this team better. Is it a successful offseason? Quietly, I'd say yes, but again none of these moves bowl you over.
Grade: B-
CLEVELAND INDIANS
Major Signings: Mike Redmond, Mark Grudzielanek, Shelley Duncan, Austin Kearns, Russell Branyon
Major Trade Acquisitions: None
Major Losses: Kelly Shoppach, Jamey Carroll
Report: Hmm, well then there's the Indians, a team going severely backwards as they've shed most of their stars in the last couple of years, instead going with whatever good youth they have. Unfortunately, some of that youth is questionable, and they didn't do anything this off-season to help themselves. Heck Mike Redmond is the only guy listed as a major league signing, I put the other guys in because I felt bad! They brought back Russell Branyon to play first again, and Jake Westbrook is finally coming back to lead their staff, but this may be the year that KC overtakes them.
Overall: A bad offseason will lead to a bad season. Anything else will be a surprise.
Grade: D
KANSAS CITY ROYALS
Major Signings: Jason Kendall, Scott Posednik, Rick Ankiel, Brian Anderson
Major Trade Acquisitions: Chris Getz, Josh Fields
Major Losses: Mark Teahen, John Buck, Mike Jacobs, Miguel Olivo, Coco Crisp
Report: They've basically signed a whole new outfield, but they still have most of their old one! Huh?! I'm not a 100% sure I understand how GM Dayton Moore operates. Not that the signings are necessarily bad, but OK, they also traded Mark Teahen for Josh Fields and Chris Getz, which clogs up their infield as well. I guess Moore is just trying to give Trey Hillman as many options as possible, but more players (like Alex Gordon and Alberto Callapso) need to start establishing themselves on this team. And with all the catchers out there this year, including their own, they signed Jason Kendall...to two years!
Overall: The only thing I can say is that Moore was trying to improve their defense. In that way, good job, but I think these signings were unnecessary overkills.
Grade: C-
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
HOT STOVE REPORT CARD: AL WEST
Part two in the Report Card series features the AL West, a division that may produce a new king led by a king...
*There are some notable players still out there like Johnny Damon, Felipe Lopez, and Russell Branyon, so we'll update these lists as we go.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
LOS ANGELS ANGELS OF ANAHEIM
Major Signings: Hideki Matsui, Fernando Rodney, Joel Piniero
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brian Stokes
Major Losses: John Lackey, Chone Figgins, Vlad Guerrero, Gary Matthews Jr., Darren Oliver, Kelvim Escobar
Report: Will this be the season that the Angels finally go down to another AL West team? (Namely the Mariners) With the loss of a boatload of major players, it could very well be. The loss of their ace, John Lackey, will hurt the most. His replacement? Joel Piniero, who I really think will be a major bust outside of Dave Duncan's care. I believe they upgraded at DH with Hideki Matsui over Vlad Guerrero, as long as Godzilla can stay of the DL that is. Chone Figgins will be very hard to replace both at third and at the top of their line-up. They'll once again try to break in Brandon Wood, but Maicer Izturis will probably be there before long. Fernando Rodney gives them a second closer with Brian Fuentes, which may or may not be a good thing.
Overall: This is still a great team, but Seattle has improved alot, and no one really knows how much the Angels will be affected by their losses. The third base situation needs to be clear once they open the season, as it'll affect the line-up as well. Will Scott Kazmir bounce back? And how exactly will Mr. Piniero fare?
Grade: B-
TEXAS RANGERS
Major Signings: Vlad Guerrero, Rich Harden, Khalil Greene, Darren Oliver, Colby Lewis
Major Trade Acquisitions: Chris Ray
Major Losses: Marlon Byrd, Omar Vizquel, Kevin Millwood
Report: Have the Rangers improved themselves? Good question. They brought in Vlad Guerrero, who may or may not have anything left. In this park, though, he may be revitalized. He should provide stability to their DH spot at least. Marlon Bryd's departure clears up their outfield a bit where Josh Hamilton hopes to rebound after an injury-plagued season. They traded away Kevin Millwood, and added the younger Rich Harden, who still has a lot of upside if he can stay healthy. This may be the best change for the team. They also swapped out Omar Vizquel for Khalil Greene as their infield sub. At one time Greene was considered quite the upcoming shortstop, but injuries and issues have led to this role. Adding Chris Ray and Darren Olivier to their bullpen is a boon, and the interesting addition of Colby Lewis fresh off a great Japanese stint could a sleeper of a rotational signing. They've also shed Hank Blalock, who remains unsigned, meaning Chris Davis has one last shot to prove something, as Justin Smoak is breathing down his neck.
Overall: I think this team is indeed better. While none of these moves blow you away, they should help, and with the possible emergence of Seattle, anything helps.
Grade: B
SEATTLE MARINERS
Major Signings: Chone Figgins, Ryan Garko, Eric Brynes
Major Trade Acquisitions: Cliff Lee, Casey Kotchman, Milton Bradley, Brandon League
Major Losses: Carlos Silva, Adrian Beltre, Brandon Morrow
Report: The Mariners have done pretty well this off-season, quite possibly better than anyone else they improved their club by leaps and bounds, mostly because the acquisition of a second ace in Cliff Lee is just a brilliant move. Lee teamed with King Felix gives them the best one-two in baseball. While the rest of the rotation is unproven, the top two will take so much pressure off of them, they may just deliver quietly good seasons. They also replaced Adrian Beltre with Chone Figgins, which gives them a great top of the line-up teaming with Ichiro. Figgins brings speed, a good eye, and good defense to the team. They swapped bad contract and no value in Carlos Silva for bad contract with some value in Milton Bradley. Sure he's a pain, but is bat is still good, and he won't kill you in the outfield. Eric Byrnes was added for defense as a fourth outfielder as well. Their first base situation now has great defender Casey Kotchman starting with Ryan Garko's bat backing him up. Brandon Morrow was traded for Brandon League which helps their bullpen in front of David Aardsma.
Overall: I dug this team's moves quite alot. Again, the Lee trade was fantastic, and the Bradley trade made bad money work. Their defense will be great, and Figgins will totally jump start this team. They may miss Russell Branyon's big bat, but they've done enough to possibly cover that loss. For sure, they are the team to watch this year.
Grade: A
OAKLAND A'S
Major Signings: Ben Sheets, Coco Crisp, Jack Cust, Justin Duchscherer, Gabe Gross
Major Trade Acquisitions: Kevin Kouzmanoff, Adam Rosales, Jake Fox
Major Losses: Scott Hairston, Adam Kennedy, Bobby Crosby
Report: Ladies and Gentlemen, the A's present their 2010 trade deadline chip: Ben Sheets! Is there any doubt about it? I mean why else would they pay Sheets 10 mil? In the meantime, he can throw some real ace wisdom to their burgeoning staff. They traded for Kevin Kouzmanoff to take over third base, while returning Scott Hairston back to the Padres. That cleared their outfield to bring in Coco Crisp, to lead Rajai Davis and Ryan Sweeney to greatness? Maybe? I do like Davis of the three at least. Old favorites Jack Cust and Justin Duchscherer were brought back, and a couple of young back-ups were traded for in moves that saw Wily Taveras pass through their system on the way to unwanted free agency.
Overall: Not the worst moves, but Oakland is in severe need of finding out who their core really is. Sheets may net them more prospects, but at some point these players need to distinguish themselves. I don't see these guys doing too well overall this year, which falls right into Billy Beane's Sheets plan, but some of these pitchers have potential. That's a start.
Grade: C
*There are some notable players still out there like Johnny Damon, Felipe Lopez, and Russell Branyon, so we'll update these lists as we go.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
LOS ANGELS ANGELS OF ANAHEIM
Major Signings: Hideki Matsui, Fernando Rodney, Joel Piniero
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brian Stokes
Major Losses: John Lackey, Chone Figgins, Vlad Guerrero, Gary Matthews Jr., Darren Oliver, Kelvim Escobar
Report: Will this be the season that the Angels finally go down to another AL West team? (Namely the Mariners) With the loss of a boatload of major players, it could very well be. The loss of their ace, John Lackey, will hurt the most. His replacement? Joel Piniero, who I really think will be a major bust outside of Dave Duncan's care. I believe they upgraded at DH with Hideki Matsui over Vlad Guerrero, as long as Godzilla can stay of the DL that is. Chone Figgins will be very hard to replace both at third and at the top of their line-up. They'll once again try to break in Brandon Wood, but Maicer Izturis will probably be there before long. Fernando Rodney gives them a second closer with Brian Fuentes, which may or may not be a good thing.
Overall: This is still a great team, but Seattle has improved alot, and no one really knows how much the Angels will be affected by their losses. The third base situation needs to be clear once they open the season, as it'll affect the line-up as well. Will Scott Kazmir bounce back? And how exactly will Mr. Piniero fare?
Grade: B-
TEXAS RANGERS
Major Signings: Vlad Guerrero, Rich Harden, Khalil Greene, Darren Oliver, Colby Lewis
Major Trade Acquisitions: Chris Ray
Major Losses: Marlon Byrd, Omar Vizquel, Kevin Millwood
Report: Have the Rangers improved themselves? Good question. They brought in Vlad Guerrero, who may or may not have anything left. In this park, though, he may be revitalized. He should provide stability to their DH spot at least. Marlon Bryd's departure clears up their outfield a bit where Josh Hamilton hopes to rebound after an injury-plagued season. They traded away Kevin Millwood, and added the younger Rich Harden, who still has a lot of upside if he can stay healthy. This may be the best change for the team. They also swapped out Omar Vizquel for Khalil Greene as their infield sub. At one time Greene was considered quite the upcoming shortstop, but injuries and issues have led to this role. Adding Chris Ray and Darren Olivier to their bullpen is a boon, and the interesting addition of Colby Lewis fresh off a great Japanese stint could a sleeper of a rotational signing. They've also shed Hank Blalock, who remains unsigned, meaning Chris Davis has one last shot to prove something, as Justin Smoak is breathing down his neck.
Overall: I think this team is indeed better. While none of these moves blow you away, they should help, and with the possible emergence of Seattle, anything helps.
Grade: B
SEATTLE MARINERS
Major Signings: Chone Figgins, Ryan Garko, Eric Brynes
Major Trade Acquisitions: Cliff Lee, Casey Kotchman, Milton Bradley, Brandon League
Major Losses: Carlos Silva, Adrian Beltre, Brandon Morrow
Report: The Mariners have done pretty well this off-season, quite possibly better than anyone else they improved their club by leaps and bounds, mostly because the acquisition of a second ace in Cliff Lee is just a brilliant move. Lee teamed with King Felix gives them the best one-two in baseball. While the rest of the rotation is unproven, the top two will take so much pressure off of them, they may just deliver quietly good seasons. They also replaced Adrian Beltre with Chone Figgins, which gives them a great top of the line-up teaming with Ichiro. Figgins brings speed, a good eye, and good defense to the team. They swapped bad contract and no value in Carlos Silva for bad contract with some value in Milton Bradley. Sure he's a pain, but is bat is still good, and he won't kill you in the outfield. Eric Byrnes was added for defense as a fourth outfielder as well. Their first base situation now has great defender Casey Kotchman starting with Ryan Garko's bat backing him up. Brandon Morrow was traded for Brandon League which helps their bullpen in front of David Aardsma.
Overall: I dug this team's moves quite alot. Again, the Lee trade was fantastic, and the Bradley trade made bad money work. Their defense will be great, and Figgins will totally jump start this team. They may miss Russell Branyon's big bat, but they've done enough to possibly cover that loss. For sure, they are the team to watch this year.
Grade: A
OAKLAND A'S
Major Signings: Ben Sheets, Coco Crisp, Jack Cust, Justin Duchscherer, Gabe Gross
Major Trade Acquisitions: Kevin Kouzmanoff, Adam Rosales, Jake Fox
Major Losses: Scott Hairston, Adam Kennedy, Bobby Crosby
Report: Ladies and Gentlemen, the A's present their 2010 trade deadline chip: Ben Sheets! Is there any doubt about it? I mean why else would they pay Sheets 10 mil? In the meantime, he can throw some real ace wisdom to their burgeoning staff. They traded for Kevin Kouzmanoff to take over third base, while returning Scott Hairston back to the Padres. That cleared their outfield to bring in Coco Crisp, to lead Rajai Davis and Ryan Sweeney to greatness? Maybe? I do like Davis of the three at least. Old favorites Jack Cust and Justin Duchscherer were brought back, and a couple of young back-ups were traded for in moves that saw Wily Taveras pass through their system on the way to unwanted free agency.
Overall: Not the worst moves, but Oakland is in severe need of finding out who their core really is. Sheets may net them more prospects, but at some point these players need to distinguish themselves. I don't see these guys doing too well overall this year, which falls right into Billy Beane's Sheets plan, but some of these pitchers have potential. That's a start.
Grade: C
Monday, February 15, 2010
HOT STOVE REPORT CARD: AL EAST
UPDATED: I started this list a couple of weeks ago as a "progress report", but never had the chance to continue. Now with pitchers and catchers reporting this week, effectively beginning Spring Training, and bringing the Hot Stove season to a close, it's a good time get this out there as a "report card". Again, we'll do these one division at a time. This first one has been updated, but the "needs" part has been taken out, instead we'll go with an expanded "report" section and an "overall" section.
* There are some notable players still out there like Johnny Damon, Felipe Lopez, and Russell Branyon, so we'll update these lists as we go.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
NEW YORK YANKEES
Major Signings: Andy Pettitte, Nick Johnson, Randy Winn, Marcus Thames
Major Trade Acquisitions: Curtis Granderson, Javier Vasquez
Major Losses: Hideki Matsui, Melky Cabrera, Brian Bruney, Ian Kennedy, Austin Jackson, Eric Hinske, Jerry Hairston Jr., Chien-Ming Wang
Report: The World Champs have been one of the big winners of the off-season while uncharacteristically setting a budget for themselves that they actually stuck to. They re-upped with one of their boys, Andy Pettitte, and brought back Javy Vasquez to the rotation. This gives them a solid 1-4, with the final spot most likely going to either Phil Hughes or Joba Chamberlain. Vasquez was one last year's better pitchers, having a near Cy Young-worthy season with Atlanta. His first stay in NY ended rather badly, but this is a much more mature pitcher, and I think this was an excellent trade. With fan-favorite Melky Cabrera gone in this deal, center field now belongs to former Tiger, Curtis Granderson. This was the Yanks' biggest splash of the off-season, unloading a few very good prospects to grab a guy who, on paper, seems like a perfect fit for this team. Nick Johnson was also brought back, this time to fill the DH hole created by Hideki Matui's flight to the Angels. Johnson is a fantastic on-base machine and should slot into the number 2 hole Johnny Damon used occupy. To further cement Damon's departure, they brought in Randy Winn and Marcus Thames, both of whom will compete with Brett Gardner to fill the left field spot. I expect the incumbant to beat his older competitors and Winn to be the fourth outfielder.
Overall: I think the Yanks did well to replace Damon and Matsui, although the question remains should they have? There's no doubt that both men fit this team well, but you can't argue with a young player like Granderson, and if Johnson can stay healthy his OBP will make up for any lost power. The Vasquez trade is huge, as you're adding a Cy Young candidate to be your #3 or 4.
Grade: A
BOSTON RED SOX
Major Signings: John Lackey, Mike Cameron, Adrian Beltre, Marco Scutaro
Major Trade Acquisitions: Jeremy Hermida, Bill Hall
Major Losses: Jason Bay, Billy Wagner, Casey Kotchman, Takashi Saito
Report: The Red Sox almost feel like a different team. Their core remains the same with the exception of Jason Bay going to the Mets. The plan is to move Jacoby Ellsbury to left, and their new acquisition Mike Cameron to patrol center. Cameron is an excellent center-fielder, but is aging. If unfazed by that he could be very valuable. They also added Adrian Beltre to play third base, even though they currently still have Mike Lowell on the roster. They were close to trading him to Texas, so don't be surprised if he's gone by Spring Training. Beltre and Cameron should make up for the loss of Bay's pop, and both provide excellent defense. Marco Scutaro finally became an everyday player in Toronto, did very well, and got himself a two year deal with a great team. If he can duplicate last season, Boston finally has themselves a shortstop. Bigger than all three of those is the signing of pitcher John Lackey. The Bulldog is a perfect fit for the Sox and gives them a hell of a rotation.
Overall: Boston did very well, and now has argueably the best rotation in baseball. They will lack some power lost by Bay, but Cameron will be good for 20-25 homers, and if Beltre finds his stroke again, they'll be fine.
Grade: A
TAMPA BAY RAYS
Major Signings: None
Major Trade Acquisitions: Rafael Soriano, Kelly Shoppach
Major Losses: Akinori Iwamura
Report: The Rays didn't do much on the free-agent front, but two trade acquisitions are worth talking about. First off, they traded for Rafael Soriano who will be their new closer, moving J.P. Howell to a set-up role. This gives them a nice one-two to close out games. They also acquired Kelly Shoppach from the Indians, which gives them a good catching platoon if Dioner Navarro can bounce back from a bad year. With the emergence of Ben Zobrist, the Rays shipped out Akinori Iwamura for more bullpen help. Aki was one of faces of their AL Championship team, and I don't think this happens had he not gotten injured last year. The Rays were one of the teams that flirted with Johnny Damon, but didn't have the room for him.
Overall: Another bat would've been good, but the Rays farm system is ripe and ready. Matt Joyce could be their starting Right Fielder, unless a second base prospect pushes Ben Zobrist to the outfield. Their rotation could've used a veteran presence as well, but that hasn't been the Rays' style.
Grade: B-
TORONTO BLUE JAYS
Major Signings: John Buck, Alex Gonzalez, Kevin Gregg, Jose Molina
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brandon Morrow
Major Losses: Roy Halladay, Marco Scutaro, Brandon League
Report: The face of Toronto is gone, but the future looks bright. That pretty much sums up Toronto's off season so far. Roy Halladay, their ace and face of the franchise was finally traded to the Philadelphia Phillies for some very good prospects. Halladay made them credible, but now it will be up to their young pitching to become a force over the next few years. Brandon Morrow, acquired from the Mariners is an interesting acquisition because he can pitch in the rotation or possible anchor their bullpen. They've changed catcher and shortstop, weakening both positions, but again any major player here will come from their system sometime down the line. An interesting late signing has been Kevin Gregg who will compete for the closer role, and may have the best chance of breaking camp with the job. He does have the most experience of the candidates. They also flirted with Johnny Damon, but the team may yet grab a DH. Jermaine Dye or Carlos Delgado could fit in well on this team, performing DH duties while mentoring their young outfielders. Russell Branyon be an interesting choice as well, and a guy that could take over first base next year.
Overall: This one is pretty simple: I can't see 2010 being any good for them, but as early as 2011 you could start seeing a breakout. The Halladay trade brought over some good talent, so it'll be interesting to watch these guys grow.
Grade: B-
BALTIMORE ORIOLES
Major Signings: Mike Gonzalez, Garrett Atkins, Miguel Tejada
Major Trade Acquisitions: Kevin Millwood
Major Losses: Chris Ray, Danys Baez
Report: Quietly, the O's have made some decent moves this off-season. First off, they answered their closer question mark with Mike Gonzalez, who is in his prime and gearing to go. He split a platoon closer role in Atlanta with Rafael Soriano, and funny enough both are now closing in the AL East. They bolstered the top of their rotation with the sturdy Kevin Millwood, who may do wonders for their young rotation. They also signed Garrett Atkins to play first base, and have returned Miguel Tejada to play 3rd. If Atkins can return to form, the O's have made a great cheap signing there. Tejada still has something left in his bat, and he did well in Balto the first time around. Promising rookie Michael Aubrey will get a look at first base as well, so their corner situation should be interesting this year.
Overall: O's fans should rejoice, their team is getting better. While not in the league of the top two yet, they should overtake Toronto this year and challenge the Rays as well. Their core of Markakis, Jones, and Guthrie are joined by the emergence of Nolan Reimold and some young pitching, and also with closer Gonzalez. I look forward to my yearly trip.
Grade: B+
* There are some notable players still out there like Johnny Damon, Felipe Lopez, and Russell Branyon, so we'll update these lists as we go.
**Please note unsigned players do not yet count as a loss.
NEW YORK YANKEES
Major Signings: Andy Pettitte, Nick Johnson, Randy Winn, Marcus Thames
Major Trade Acquisitions: Curtis Granderson, Javier Vasquez
Major Losses: Hideki Matsui, Melky Cabrera, Brian Bruney, Ian Kennedy, Austin Jackson, Eric Hinske, Jerry Hairston Jr., Chien-Ming Wang
Report: The World Champs have been one of the big winners of the off-season while uncharacteristically setting a budget for themselves that they actually stuck to. They re-upped with one of their boys, Andy Pettitte, and brought back Javy Vasquez to the rotation. This gives them a solid 1-4, with the final spot most likely going to either Phil Hughes or Joba Chamberlain. Vasquez was one last year's better pitchers, having a near Cy Young-worthy season with Atlanta. His first stay in NY ended rather badly, but this is a much more mature pitcher, and I think this was an excellent trade. With fan-favorite Melky Cabrera gone in this deal, center field now belongs to former Tiger, Curtis Granderson. This was the Yanks' biggest splash of the off-season, unloading a few very good prospects to grab a guy who, on paper, seems like a perfect fit for this team. Nick Johnson was also brought back, this time to fill the DH hole created by Hideki Matui's flight to the Angels. Johnson is a fantastic on-base machine and should slot into the number 2 hole Johnny Damon used occupy. To further cement Damon's departure, they brought in Randy Winn and Marcus Thames, both of whom will compete with Brett Gardner to fill the left field spot. I expect the incumbant to beat his older competitors and Winn to be the fourth outfielder.
Overall: I think the Yanks did well to replace Damon and Matsui, although the question remains should they have? There's no doubt that both men fit this team well, but you can't argue with a young player like Granderson, and if Johnson can stay healthy his OBP will make up for any lost power. The Vasquez trade is huge, as you're adding a Cy Young candidate to be your #3 or 4.
Grade: A
BOSTON RED SOX
Major Signings: John Lackey, Mike Cameron, Adrian Beltre, Marco Scutaro
Major Trade Acquisitions: Jeremy Hermida, Bill Hall
Major Losses: Jason Bay, Billy Wagner, Casey Kotchman, Takashi Saito
Report: The Red Sox almost feel like a different team. Their core remains the same with the exception of Jason Bay going to the Mets. The plan is to move Jacoby Ellsbury to left, and their new acquisition Mike Cameron to patrol center. Cameron is an excellent center-fielder, but is aging. If unfazed by that he could be very valuable. They also added Adrian Beltre to play third base, even though they currently still have Mike Lowell on the roster. They were close to trading him to Texas, so don't be surprised if he's gone by Spring Training. Beltre and Cameron should make up for the loss of Bay's pop, and both provide excellent defense. Marco Scutaro finally became an everyday player in Toronto, did very well, and got himself a two year deal with a great team. If he can duplicate last season, Boston finally has themselves a shortstop. Bigger than all three of those is the signing of pitcher John Lackey. The Bulldog is a perfect fit for the Sox and gives them a hell of a rotation.
Overall: Boston did very well, and now has argueably the best rotation in baseball. They will lack some power lost by Bay, but Cameron will be good for 20-25 homers, and if Beltre finds his stroke again, they'll be fine.
Grade: A
TAMPA BAY RAYS
Major Signings: None
Major Trade Acquisitions: Rafael Soriano, Kelly Shoppach
Major Losses: Akinori Iwamura
Report: The Rays didn't do much on the free-agent front, but two trade acquisitions are worth talking about. First off, they traded for Rafael Soriano who will be their new closer, moving J.P. Howell to a set-up role. This gives them a nice one-two to close out games. They also acquired Kelly Shoppach from the Indians, which gives them a good catching platoon if Dioner Navarro can bounce back from a bad year. With the emergence of Ben Zobrist, the Rays shipped out Akinori Iwamura for more bullpen help. Aki was one of faces of their AL Championship team, and I don't think this happens had he not gotten injured last year. The Rays were one of the teams that flirted with Johnny Damon, but didn't have the room for him.
Overall: Another bat would've been good, but the Rays farm system is ripe and ready. Matt Joyce could be their starting Right Fielder, unless a second base prospect pushes Ben Zobrist to the outfield. Their rotation could've used a veteran presence as well, but that hasn't been the Rays' style.
Grade: B-
TORONTO BLUE JAYS
Major Signings: John Buck, Alex Gonzalez, Kevin Gregg, Jose Molina
Major Trade Acquisitions: Brandon Morrow
Major Losses: Roy Halladay, Marco Scutaro, Brandon League
Report: The face of Toronto is gone, but the future looks bright. That pretty much sums up Toronto's off season so far. Roy Halladay, their ace and face of the franchise was finally traded to the Philadelphia Phillies for some very good prospects. Halladay made them credible, but now it will be up to their young pitching to become a force over the next few years. Brandon Morrow, acquired from the Mariners is an interesting acquisition because he can pitch in the rotation or possible anchor their bullpen. They've changed catcher and shortstop, weakening both positions, but again any major player here will come from their system sometime down the line. An interesting late signing has been Kevin Gregg who will compete for the closer role, and may have the best chance of breaking camp with the job. He does have the most experience of the candidates. They also flirted with Johnny Damon, but the team may yet grab a DH. Jermaine Dye or Carlos Delgado could fit in well on this team, performing DH duties while mentoring their young outfielders. Russell Branyon be an interesting choice as well, and a guy that could take over first base next year.
Overall: This one is pretty simple: I can't see 2010 being any good for them, but as early as 2011 you could start seeing a breakout. The Halladay trade brought over some good talent, so it'll be interesting to watch these guys grow.
Grade: B-
BALTIMORE ORIOLES
Major Signings: Mike Gonzalez, Garrett Atkins, Miguel Tejada
Major Trade Acquisitions: Kevin Millwood
Major Losses: Chris Ray, Danys Baez
Report: Quietly, the O's have made some decent moves this off-season. First off, they answered their closer question mark with Mike Gonzalez, who is in his prime and gearing to go. He split a platoon closer role in Atlanta with Rafael Soriano, and funny enough both are now closing in the AL East. They bolstered the top of their rotation with the sturdy Kevin Millwood, who may do wonders for their young rotation. They also signed Garrett Atkins to play first base, and have returned Miguel Tejada to play 3rd. If Atkins can return to form, the O's have made a great cheap signing there. Tejada still has something left in his bat, and he did well in Balto the first time around. Promising rookie Michael Aubrey will get a look at first base as well, so their corner situation should be interesting this year.
Overall: O's fans should rejoice, their team is getting better. While not in the league of the top two yet, they should overtake Toronto this year and challenge the Rays as well. Their core of Markakis, Jones, and Guthrie are joined by the emergence of Nolan Reimold and some young pitching, and also with closer Gonzalez. I look forward to my yearly trip.
Grade: B+
Monday, February 8, 2010
EXPANSION
Just for the hell of it recently, I created an alltime database of team performance, beginning with the formation of the American League in 1901. I assigned 20 points for a championship, 8 points for a pennant, 4 points for winning a division or a division series, and 2 points for losing a division series. I don't exactly remember what I did for 1994 and the years before the World Series, but partial credit was assigned for those seasons.
By this method, the Yankees are shown to have completely dominated baseball for most of their existence. Sal won't have a problem with that, but I'll admit to being annoyed that the Yankees are somehow 2.41 times as successful as the second best team in history, the St. Louis Cardinals. Interestingly, the 8 worst franchises are all expansion teams. Possibly because of the difficulties involved in starting from scratch, possibly because baseball has never expanded into a large-market city unless it already had an existing team. So, if you believe that baseball has overexpanded, like I do, this seems to prove it.
Here's the list of the 30 baseball franchises, ranked by postseason results. The first number is PPPS (postseason points per season), the second is titles won since the expansion era began in 1961.
1. New York Yankees /Baltimore Orioles 6.11, won in 2009, 2000, 1999, 1998, 1996, 1978, 1977, 1962, 1961, etc
2. St. Louis Cardinals 2.53, won in 2006, 1982, 1967, 1964
3. Florida Marlins 2.35, won in 2003, 1997
4. Oakland /Kansas City /Philadelphia A's, 2.35, won in 1989, 1974, 1973, 1972
5. Arizona Diamondbacks 2.33, only title 2001
6. Los Angeles /Brooklyn Dodgers 2.22, won in 1988, 1981, 1965, 1963
7. San Francisco /New York Giants 2.00, last won in 1954
8. Boston Red Sox 1.91, won in 2007, 2004
9. Toronto Blue Jays 1.58, won in 1993, 1992
10. Pittsburgh Pirates 1.47, won in 1979, 1971
11. New York Mets 1.42, won in 1986, 1969
12. Cincinnati Reds 1.34, won in 1990, 1976, 1975
13. Atlanta /Milwaukee /Boston Braves 1.32, won in 1995
14. Detroit Tigers 1.25, won in 1984, 1968
15. Kansas City Royals 1.12, only title 1985
16. Chicago Cubs 1.12, last won in 1908
17. Baltimore Orioles /St. Louis Browns 0.99, won in 1983, 1970, 1966
18. Minnesota Twins /Washington Senators 0.95, won in 1991, 1987
19. Los Angeles Angels 0.94, only title 2002
20. Chicago White Sox 0.90, won in 2005
21. Philadelphia Phillies 0.88, won in 2008, 1980
22. Cleveland Indians 0.73, last won in 1948
23. Colorado Rockies 0.71
24. Tampa Bay Rays 0.67
25. Houston Astros 0.63
26. San Diego Padres 0.54
27. Seattle Mariners 0.42
28. Milwaukee Brewers /Seattle Pilots 0.29
29. Texas Rangers /Washington Senators 0.16
30. Washington Nationals /Montreal Expos 0.15
The expansion success stories are the Marlins and Diamondbacks, though these are in limited sample sizes. Next are the Toronto Blue Jays, who have been stagnant for most of the last 15 years, and the New York Mets... if they're the 4th-most successful expansion franchise ever, having spent most of their existence sucking ass in the largest market in the NL... that only proves the point that expansion franchises tend to get mired in permanent cycles of losing. The Expos / Nationals made the playoffs twice in their entire existence. Maybe baseball moved them out of Montreal out of consideration for their hysterically suicidal fans.
Also, the worst franchise of the original 16 is the Indians, winners in 1920, 1948, and never before or again.
By this method, the Yankees are shown to have completely dominated baseball for most of their existence. Sal won't have a problem with that, but I'll admit to being annoyed that the Yankees are somehow 2.41 times as successful as the second best team in history, the St. Louis Cardinals. Interestingly, the 8 worst franchises are all expansion teams. Possibly because of the difficulties involved in starting from scratch, possibly because baseball has never expanded into a large-market city unless it already had an existing team. So, if you believe that baseball has overexpanded, like I do, this seems to prove it.
Here's the list of the 30 baseball franchises, ranked by postseason results. The first number is PPPS (postseason points per season), the second is titles won since the expansion era began in 1961.
1. New York Yankees /Baltimore Orioles 6.11, won in 2009, 2000, 1999, 1998, 1996, 1978, 1977, 1962, 1961, etc
2. St. Louis Cardinals 2.53, won in 2006, 1982, 1967, 1964
3. Florida Marlins 2.35, won in 2003, 1997
4. Oakland /Kansas City /Philadelphia A's, 2.35, won in 1989, 1974, 1973, 1972
5. Arizona Diamondbacks 2.33, only title 2001
6. Los Angeles /Brooklyn Dodgers 2.22, won in 1988, 1981, 1965, 1963
7. San Francisco /New York Giants 2.00, last won in 1954
8. Boston Red Sox 1.91, won in 2007, 2004
9. Toronto Blue Jays 1.58, won in 1993, 1992
10. Pittsburgh Pirates 1.47, won in 1979, 1971
11. New York Mets 1.42, won in 1986, 1969
12. Cincinnati Reds 1.34, won in 1990, 1976, 1975
13. Atlanta /Milwaukee /Boston Braves 1.32, won in 1995
14. Detroit Tigers 1.25, won in 1984, 1968
15. Kansas City Royals 1.12, only title 1985
16. Chicago Cubs 1.12, last won in 1908
17. Baltimore Orioles /St. Louis Browns 0.99, won in 1983, 1970, 1966
18. Minnesota Twins /Washington Senators 0.95, won in 1991, 1987
19. Los Angeles Angels 0.94, only title 2002
20. Chicago White Sox 0.90, won in 2005
21. Philadelphia Phillies 0.88, won in 2008, 1980
22. Cleveland Indians 0.73, last won in 1948
23. Colorado Rockies 0.71
24. Tampa Bay Rays 0.67
25. Houston Astros 0.63
26. San Diego Padres 0.54
27. Seattle Mariners 0.42
28. Milwaukee Brewers /Seattle Pilots 0.29
29. Texas Rangers /Washington Senators 0.16
30. Washington Nationals /Montreal Expos 0.15
The expansion success stories are the Marlins and Diamondbacks, though these are in limited sample sizes. Next are the Toronto Blue Jays, who have been stagnant for most of the last 15 years, and the New York Mets... if they're the 4th-most successful expansion franchise ever, having spent most of their existence sucking ass in the largest market in the NL... that only proves the point that expansion franchises tend to get mired in permanent cycles of losing. The Expos / Nationals made the playoffs twice in their entire existence. Maybe baseball moved them out of Montreal out of consideration for their hysterically suicidal fans.
Also, the worst franchise of the original 16 is the Indians, winners in 1920, 1948, and never before or again.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
Posts
